Join Our Email ListJoin Our Email List

☎ (814) 796-0060☎ (814) 796-0060

We are closed during our annual winter break from December 30th through March 3rd.
We will reopen March 4th at 11 AM.

Menu

Home
Our Menu
About Us
Contact Us

Amish Home-Cooked Meals

Delectable Restaurant Specials

Looking for a local restaurant near the Erie, PA area that can satisfy your appetite? Choose none other than Sugar 'N Spice in Waterford, PA. We serve Amish home-cooked meals that warm your heart. Come by our restaurant for dinner with friends or join us on Saturdays and Sundays for breakfast with your family. Be sure to check out our restaurant specials for great deals!

Our Amish Home-Cooked Meals Include

Homemade Soup (Cup/Bowl)

Cup $3.29/Bowl $4.29Vegetable Beef, Ham & Bean, Soup of the Day
Pint $4.99/Quart $7.99Soup to Go

Cup $3.59/Bowl $4.59New England Clam Chowder (Fridays Only)

Luncheon Salads

(Available from Wednesday through Saturday, 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM)

$6.99Your Choice

Chef Salad, Sirloin Steak, Grilled Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, Crispy Chicken, or Fried Shrimp

$0.75Add French Fries to Your Salad

Soup and Salad Combination

(Available from Wednesday through Saturday, 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM)

$6.99Choose two of the following

Cup of Soup, Tossed Salad, ½ Sandwich

Sandwich Choices: Chicken Salad, Egg Salad, Turkey and Cheese or Ham and Cheese, Served on White, Wheat, or Rye

Sugar `N Spice Original Salads

(Dressing Choices: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Italian, Thousand Island, Honey Mustard, Raspberry Vinaigrette, and Sugar ‘N Spice Original House-Style French)

$9.49Your Choice

Sirloin Steak, Grilled Chicken, Crispy Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, Fried Shrimp

$8.99Chef Salad

$0.75Add French Fries to Your Salad

$8.99Spinach Salad

Fresh Spinach, Shredded Cheese, Mushrooms, Tomatoes, Eggs, Olives, Croutons, and Real Bacon Pieces Topped With Green Peppers and Onions

$9.99With Chicken

$8.99Summer Spinach Salad

Spinach and choice of cheddar or Crumbled Blue Cheese. Onions, Tomatoes, Candied Pecans and Dried Cranberries

$9.99With Chicken

$10.49Cobb Salad

Grilled chicken, Applewood Bacon Pieces, Tomatoes, Eggs, Olives, Onions and Choice of Shredded Cheese or Crumbled Blue Cheese

$7.99Cold Plate

Chicken Salad, Cottage Cheese, Tomato Slices and Hard-Boiled Eggs

$6.99Stuffed Tomato

Chicken Salad or Tuna Salad

Sugar `N Spice Original Specials

(Specials are limited; check with your server for availability.)

(All specials are served with home-baked rolls and buttered vegetable of the day. Also, includes your choice of mashed or baked potato (after 4 p.m.) and choice of coleslaw or applesauce.)

(Substitute a tossed salad for $1.00.)

Wednesday

$9.99Cream Chicken and Biscuits

Homemade Chicken Gravy Over Biscuits With Mashed Potatoes and Amish Dressing

$9.99Beef Tips and Noodles

Slow-Roasted Beef and Our Homemade Egg Noodles

$9.99Lasagna With Garlic Bread and Choice of Salad

Our Own Family Recipe!

Thursday

$10.99Roasted Turkey with Amish Dressing

Tender and Juicy Slow-Roasted Whole Tom Turkey

Add $1.00All White Meat Turkey

$10.99Old-Fashioned Swiss Steak

9-oz. Pan-Fried Swiss Steak Baked in Our Own Gravy

Friday

$9.99Smothered Chicken Breast

Grilled Chicken Breast Smothered With Onions, Mushrooms, Applewood Bacon and Provolone Cheese

$12.99Fried or Baked Icelandic Cod

Hand-Battered or Baked With Our Own Seasoning

$14.99Baked Stuffed Icelandic Cod

With Our Original Crab Meat Stuffing

Saturday

$9.99Homemade Meatloaf

Amish-Style Recipe, Freshly Baked

$12.99Roasted Chicken

A Half chicken, seasoned and lightly fried, served with our homemade dressing

$18.9916-oz. Prime Rib

Seasoned and Slow-Roasted, Served With Au Jus

$14.99Baked Stuffed Icelandic Cod

With Our Original Crab Meat Stuffing

Sunday

$11.99Stuffed Chicken Breast

8-oz. Skin-On Boneless Chicken Breast With Our Homemade Dressing

$11.99Roasted Pork Tenderloin

Roasted In Its Own Natural Juices and Served With Amish Dressing

$11.99Baked Ham

Baked Sugar-Cured Ham

$18.9916-oz. Prime Rib

Seasoned and Slow-Roasted, Served With Au Jus

Sugar ‘N Spice Original Sandwiches

(Serve With French Fries, Toss Salad, Homemade Coleslaw, or a Cup of Soup and Dill Pickle Spears)

$7.99Chicken Breast

Choose Breaded or Grilled, Served With Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayonnaise on a brioche bun.
Add Your Choice of Cheese for $0.30

Add Bacon for $0.99

$9.49Grilled Chicken or Steak Philly Cheesesteak

Grilled Chicken Strips or Shrived Sirloin With Grilled Peppers and Onions, White American Cheese, All Served on Toasted Country Italian Bread

$9.99Club Burger

Our 8-oz Angus Reserve With Choice of Cheese, 3 Strips of Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayonnaise

$7.99Traditional BLT

5 Strips of Bacon With Lettuce, Tomato and Mayonnaise on Your Choice of White, Wheat, Rye or Grilled Panini Bread

$8.99Deluxe Club

3 Slices of Toast With Your Choice of Ham or Chicken With Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayonnaise

$6.99Egg Salad

On Your Choice of White, Wheat, or Rye Bread

$7.49Sugar 'N Spice Original Chicken Salad

On Your Choice of White, Wheat, or Rye

$8.99Angus Cheeseburger

8-oz. Angus Reserve Beef Pattie With Choice Cheese and Toppings

$8.49Angus: Hamburger

8-oz. Angus Reserve Beef Pattie With Your Choice of Toppings

$9.99Fried Fish Sandwich

Icelandic Cod Served With Lettuce, Tomato and Tartar Sauce

$5.49Frankfurter

1/4-lb. Smith's With Your Choice of Toppings

$8.99Turkey Bacon Spinach Wrap

Oven roasted sliced turkey, with cheddar jack cheese, Baby Spinach and Tomato with our homemade dill sauce

$7.99Veggie Wrap

Spinach, Tomatoes, Green pepper, Red onion, Cucumber, Black olives and cheddar jack cheese with homemade dill sauce

$9.99Ultimate Cheese Burger Wrap

6oz of fresh ground beef, choice of cheese (American, Swiss or Provolone) Lettuce, tomato, onion, bacon and pickles with our homemade thousand island dressing

$8.99Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Grilled or crispy chicken in our mild buffalo sauce, sautéed onions, lettuce and tomatoes. Ranch or blue cheese on the side.

$9.49French Dip

Shaved Ribeye, Grilled Onions, Provolone Cheese, and Au Jus

$8.99Reuben

Thinly-Sliced Corned Beef, Sauerkraut and Swiss Cheese Piled on Rye Bread

$9.49Hotel Classic

Half-Pound Angus Reserve With Grilled Onions, American Cheese and Bistro Sauce on Toasted Country Italian Bread

$8.49Hot Roast Beef or Meatloaf Sandwich

With Gravy

Served with Mashed Potatoes or Side

$8.49Chicken Cordon Bleu

Your Choice of Grilled or Breaded Chicken With Ham, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayonnaise

$8.99Turkey Club

Turkey, Bacon, American and Provolone Cheese, With Lettuce, Tomato and Mayonnaise on Texas Toast

Traditional Dinners

(Served with home-baked rolls and 2 choices of the following: potato, Amish Dressing, Baked Beans, Soup of the Day, Amish Noodles, Mac N Cheese, Buttered Vegetable of the Day, Fruit Slush, Cottage Cheese, Macaroni Salad, Potato Salad , Apple Sauce, Homemade Coleslaw or toss salad.)

$11.99/Two - $14.99Smothered Chicken Breast

Grilled Chicken Breast Smothered With Onions, Mushrooms, Applewood Bacon and Provolone Cheese

$12.991/2 Crispy Fried Chicken

Four Pieces Crispy Battered on the Outside, Tender and Juicy Inside

$10.49Breaded Chicken Tenderloins

Four Pieces Deep-Fried and Served With Your Choice of Sauce

$9.99/Two - $11.99Chicken Breast Dinner

Grilled Breast With Our Own Special Seasoning Blend

$13.99Baked Icelandic Cod

10-12 oz. filet Baked With Our Own Special Seasoning Blend (Also Available With Lemon Pepper or Cajun Seasoning)

$9.99Clam Strips

A Generous Portion, Deep-Fried and Served With Cocktail Sauce and Tartar Sauce

$11.99Butterfly Shrimp

Seven Large Shrimp Lightly-Breaded and Fried

$16.99Combination Seafood Platter

Baked or Fried Icelandic Cod, Fried Shrimp, and Clam Strips

$10.99Choice Roast Beef

Slow-Roasted for 10 Hours in Its Own Natural Juices

$10.99Liver and Onions

Grilled Beef Liver With Sautéed Onions

$10.99Homemade Meatloaf

Amish-Style Recipe Baked Fresh

$10.99/Two - $13.99Country-Style Pork Chop

8-oz. Center Cut, T-Bone Chop

$13.99Broasted Chicken

One Half chicken seasoned and lightly fried, served with our homemade dressing

$11.9912-oz. Ham Steak

Delicious Boneless Sugar-Cured Ham

$12.998-oz. Marinated Flat Iron Steak

$11.99Fried Shrimp Dinner

15 Pieces Deep-Fried With Crispy Breading

$1.00 EachSteak

Add Grilled Onions, Peppers or Mushrooms

$3.99 Add 5 Butterfly Shrimp

$17.99 14-oz. Delmonico Steak

$11.99 16-oz. Chopped Sirloin

$15.99 12-oz. Top Sirloin Steak

$12.99 Fish N Chips

10-oz. Cod Lightly-Breaded and Fried, Served With French fries and Your Choice of Salad

Pasta

Served With Garlic Bread and Choice of Salad

$8.99 Spaghetti With Our Own Tomato Sauce

$11.99Chicken Parmesan With Spaghetti

$10.99 Sandwich Platter

Roast Beef of Meatloaf, Served on Texas Toast With Salad and Choice of Potato

(2)Meats -$13.99/(3)Meats-$16.99Sugar N Spice Amish-Style Sampler

Choose from Roast Beef, Homemade Meatloaf, Country-Style Pork Chop, Ham Steak, Chicken Tenderloins, Grilled Chicken Breast, Fried Shrimp, Clam Strips

Consumer Advisory: Consuming raw or undercooked meat, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness

$2.99Fries

$4.99Sweet Potato Fries

$4.59Onion Rings

$5.99Cheese Sticks

$2.99Homemade Amish Dressing

$2.99Real Mashed Potatoes

$3.99Garlic Bread

$2.99Amish Noodles

$1.99Baked Beans

$2.99Mac and Cheese

$2.39Cottage Cheese

$2.99Potato Salad (Seasonal)

$3.99Tossed Salad

$2.49Homemade Coleslaw

$2.99Macaroni Salad (Seasonal)

$1.49Buttered Vegetable of the Day

$1.59Fruit Slush

(Homemade Pies – Sugar ‘N Spice Original Style – Check with your server for your favorites!)

$3.79Fruit Pies

Apple, Cherry, Blackberry, Blueberry, Wild Berry, Fruits of the Forest

$3.79Cream Pies

Chocolate Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter, Graham Cracker, Coconut Cream, Banana Cream

$4.99Pie Ala Mode

$1.99Hand-Dipped Vanilla Ice Cream

$12.99Whole Cream Pie

$12.99Whole Fruit Pie

(BYOB – Beer and Wine Only)

$1.89Coffee

Regular or Decaffeinated

$1.89Hot Tea

$1.89Hot Chocolate

Topped With Whipped Cream

Small - $1.39/Large - $1.99Milk

Regular or Chocolate

$2.39Iced Tea

Regular or Raspberry (Free Refills)

$2.39Lemonade (Free Refills)

$2.39Soft Drinks (Free Refills)

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Mello Yello, or Root Beer

$1.89Fruit Juice

Apple, Orange, or Tomato

Tasty Pork Chop Dinner with Vegetables

Try Our Amish Home-Cooked Meals

Each meal we serve is carefully prepared by our kitchen staff. We make sure to use only the finest and freshest ingredients to prepare our dishes. Try our Amish home-cooked meals today and see why other customers keep coming back for more. Dial our number if you have inquiries about our restaurant specials.

Sugar 'N Spice

32 High Street

Waterford, PA

troyerinc@yahoo.com